Agricultural SubsidiesAgriculture PolicyBriefingBt cotton

Harish Damodaran on How Radha Mohan Singh’s Orders Denying Pricing and Licensing Freedom are Reversing the Cotton Revolution

Farmers pushing out cotton from a truck at a mandi in Mehsana, Gujarat. Photo by Vivian Fernandes

In an article in the Indian Express, Harish Damodaran writes that the government’s contempt for intellectual property rights in the agricultural sector could reverse last decade’s gains in the cotton sector and once again turn India into a net cotton importer.

As this website has argued, Damodaran holds the December 2015 order of the agriculture ministry denying pricing freedom to the owner of the bollworm-killing Bt cotton trait, that is Monsanto (now merged in Bayer) and the May 2016 notification (since withdrawn) compelling it to provide the trait on demand to seed companies  (a denial of licensing freedom) responsible.

A year after the genetically-modified Bt cotton trait was approved for cultivation (2002), India was the world’s third largest cotton producer (3.05 million tonnes) after China (5.19 million tonnes) and the United States (3.98 million tonnes).

Quoting the US Department of Agriculture, he says India was the third largest exporter (0.15 million tonnes) but imports at 0.17 million kg exceeded exports.

In 2006-17, India overtook the US to become the largest producer. It also became the second largest exporter (at 1.06 million tonnes) but way behind the US (2.83 million tonnes).

By 2011-12, India’s output (6.32 million tonnes) was twice that of the US (3.39 million tonnes) and its exports (2.42 million tonnes) came close to that of the US (2.55 million tonnes).

India’s production peaked in 2013-14 at 6.76 million tonnes. In 2015-16, it beat China (4.89 million tonnes) to become the largest producer.

In 2018-19, China regained is No 1 position with an output of 6 million tonnes, slightly higher than India’s 5.89 million tonnes.

But India’s exports have dropped from a peak of 2.42 million tonnes in 2011-12 to 0.98 million tonnes in 2018-19. The US exported 3.27 million tonnes of cotton last year or 81.6 percent of its output. (The US gives massive cotton subsidies).

Damodaran says secondary pest attacks like that of the pink bollworm (a borer) and sap suckers like the whitefly have reduced India’s yield from 511 kg per hectare in 2014-15 to 484 kg per ha in 2015-16. After recovering to 542 kg in 2016-17, it fell to 507 kg in 2017-18.

While yields are influenced by multiple factors including weather and soil quality, Damodaran holds this government and the previous one also responsible. Their “outright hostility” to GM crop breeding, be it herbicide-tolerant Bt cotton, Bt brinjal and GM maize, have brought India to this pass.

Damodaran says the latest Bt cotton price control order, reducing the price per packet of 450 grams by Rs 10 will mean a saving of Rs 15-20 per acre. This is peanuts compared to the cost of cultivation of cotton, which is Rs 15,500 per acre in rainfed conditions and Rs 24,000 per acre in irrigation conditions. (The yields on average are 5 quintals per acre and 8 quintals respectively).

But the trait fee reduction of Rs 19 per packet will hit Monsanto hard. Little wonder, it withdrew the application for commercial approval of herbicide-tolerant Bt cotton in July 2016. Farmers are now using an unapproved version of that technology on a large-scale but they face the risk of poor quality seeds which might result in weeds developing resistance faster than if the technology owner were in control.

(Top photo: Farmers pushing out cotton from a truck at a mandi in Mehsana in Gujarat.  By Vivian Fernandes)

Related posts
Agriculture Policy

Congress Manifesto Should Have Promised Income Support to Smallholder Farmers Rather than Legal Backing for MSP

This article by Vivian Fernandes first appeared in The Congress Party’s promise to…
Read more
Agriculture Policy

Peace Clause Will Not Buy Durable Peace for India at the WTO, Analyst Says

The ‘peace clause’ agreed at the  9th ministerial conference (MC) of the World Trade…
Read more
Agriculture Policy

Any Crop Combination That Doesn't Include Paddy is Not the Most Profitable

Even if there is assured procurement at minimum support prices (MSP) of other crops, any combination…
Read more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *